You should be able to get the metal collar at a speed shop. I think I paid $12 for mine. I do not know what the symptom was for you to pull the pan and pump, but if the pump was providing sufficient pressure I would reinstall it. The pickup is a RPITA to put on the pump correctly. I believe the collar has caused more pumps to be replaced than need be. If the collar breaks, the symptom is the same as a bad pump, and a garage will replace the pump to be on the safe side. There are kits to rebuild the pump, and you can rebuild the pump you have as well. The only pump I ever replaced was one where the relief valve was stuck, overpressured the engine, and squirted the oil filter gasket out, then the oil behind it (made a V spray pattern all the way across the street).